Why are Castle ESCs so expensive?

[Boomer]

What is so different about the Castle ESC compared to others? The two ESCs pictured below are similar but worlds apart price wise.

Not looking to run down any one product, just to understand why someone would pay so much more for one over the other.
Thank you
Boomer

[Hydromaniac]

What is so different about the Castle ESC compared to others? The two ESCs pictured below are similar but worlds apart price wise.

Not looking to run down any one product, just to understand why someone would pay so much more for one over the other.
Thank you
Boomer

You know the saying you get what you pay for!!
IMO the castle is a far better product, and service if something goes wrong. I have ran them both and there is no comparison.

[RaceMechaniX]

Another big difference in the retail cost between the two is the overhead and R&D that goes into them. Castle does the R&D here in the States and provides excellent customer service. The copy cat companies simply wait till someone releases a good product, reverse engineer it and then turn around manufacture and rebadge and sell it for a fraction of the cost.

Tyler

[RIPFENCE]

why do we not see any schulze copycats then?

[Boomer]

Still looking for some sort of specific or tech reason

Thank you and I really appreciate your responses. I am hoping for something more specific.

Since you have owned and operated both, can you define "there is no comparison"? Is it made differently? Does it run cooler?Did it last longer? Do they have lower failure rates? Does it make the boat faster?

What happened to the Turnigy? Have you had a service or failure issue with the Castle that you can share, and what happened with the other brand to bring you to your conclusions?

The warranty and/or tech support aspect is of course of value, especially if you have ever tried to get warranty or tech support from Hobby King. I do know someone that did return an ESC (aircraft style) to HK and got a replacement, but it took 3 to 4 months, and some wrangling to get them to do it.

I have not heard or read postings on either of these brands in regard to them failing. I am just trying to get some hard data, so I can justify spending, at least twice the amount on the Castle.

I suspect, most failures of ESC's are the results of improper applications or abuse by the user. I am trying to learn how to spec batteries to ESC's, to motors, to props. I have a long way to go.

I read as many posts as I can in the hope of avoiding a melt down. I have smoked one ESC, and don't want to do it again. It was 100% my fault, and the damage was only to the ESC, so I consider myself fortunate and have learned from that experience. I am more careful know, and understand the difference between in "series" and in "parallel", so I am making some progress.

I am not looking for "feelings" about the differences. The old saying of "you get what you pay for", is not as accurate as it used to be. I look at it from a more jaded point of view. I think you get what you pay for, if you know what your are buying, and you won't if you don't.

Times have changed, and integrity is not a very common thing any more. Bitter, no, I've just been around a long time and 35 years of being in the business world have brought me to this conclusion.

I like to be an educated buyer, and this and other RC forums have provided invaluable information to help me become a better buyer. Thus, my questions today.

Again, thank you for responding!
Boomer

[Doby]

You are paying a lot for the "name".....for better or worse.

[RaceMechaniX]

why do we not see any schulze copycats then?

There probably are Schulze copy cats, but I believe the footprint (being flat and long) makes its less attractive to copy as they do not fit in many appications. Nice small compact units like Castle or MGM are easier to sell as a universal one size fits all esc.

The Schulzes and YGE look awfully close, but controller design does not deviate very far from good practices so I would expect them to be similar. Same with Castle and MGM. I believe they both are mostly original designs. but they look very familiar.

Also, Schulze may use some more expensive materials and perhaps more sophisticated PCB design which makes it harder to copy.

This is all speculative and just my opinion.

Tyler

[Doby]

why do we not see any schulze copycats then?

Because German Engineering can't be copied

[Hydromaniac]

I race and every turnigy I have owned has failed in a very short time under race conditions, Tunigy did not stand behind the product at all. Then on The other hand I have owned and raced with over 15 Castle Esc,s with only 1 failure @ 2 years old, and Castle Replaced it no charge in a matter of days. Also Castle Creations is a Fantastic supporter of Organized racing. I have never seen anything from Turnigy. Just another bennifit from Castle IMO.

[Ub Hauled]

there are the materials as well... if you unwrap the CC and the Turnigy you'll probably notice that the MOSFETS are not the same, that solders are done differently, different CAPS and probably less pure copper on the board... and those are only the items that are more visible...

[RIPFENCE]

i guess it depends on what you value the most...there is no esc out there that is bullet proof..especially in boats when you have many variables/situations that can cause failures..i have run many of the rabadged as well as castles..i am going to give my honest opinion based on both...i am just a sport boater and not a racer..i have had more luck with the turnigy brands then castles...some here will tell you the exact opposite...but in the end castle is going to hit you again for a repaired esc...its not what i would consider a cheap repair service either..i would rather take my chances with knock offs and save money from the get go..i am going to try the castle hydra ice series when it comes out..and it may sway me to castles side...but right now i would rather have 3 turnigy 180's then one castle hydra 240 for sport boating purposes

[RaceMechaniX]

Thank you and I really appreciate your response. I am hoping for something more specific.

Since you have owned and operated both, can you define "there is no comparison"? Is it made differently? Does it run cooler?Did it last longer? Do they have lower failure rates? Does it make the boat faster?

What happened to the Turnigy? Have you had a service or failure issue with the Castle that you can share, and what happened with the other brand to bring you to your conclusions?

The warranty and/or tech support aspect is of course of value, especially if you have ever tried to get warranty or tech support from Hobby King. I do know someone that did return an ESC (aircraft style) to HK and got a replacement, but it took 3 to 4 months, and some wrangling to get them to do it.

I have not heard or read postings on either of these brands in regard to them failing. I am just trying to get some hard data, so I can justify spending, at least twice the amount on the Castle.

I suspect, most failures of ESC's are the results of improper applications or abuse by the user. I am trying to learn how to spec batteries to ESC's, to motors, to props. I have a long way to go.

I read as many posts as I can in the hope of avoiding a melt down. I have smoked one ESC, and don't want to do it again. It was 100% my fault, and the damage was only to the ESC, so I consider myself fortunate and have learned from that experience. I am more careful know, and understand the difference between in "series" and in "parallel", so I am making some progress.

I am not looking for "feelings" about the differences. The old saying of "you get what you pay for", is not as accurate as it used to be. I look at it from a more jaded point of view. I think you get what you pay for, if you know what your are buying, and you won't if you don't.

Times have changed, and integrity is not a very common thing any more. Bitter, no, I've just been around a long time and 35 years of being in the business world have brought me to this conclusion.

I like to be an educated buyer, and this and other RC forums have provided invaluable information to help me become a better buyer. Thus, my questions today.

Again, thank you for responding!
Boomer

Boomer,

They are many similarities and differences and many good reasons to buy on over another. The old adage "you get what you pay for" is mostly correct when you look at the global view. When you look zero in on the price point it comes down to materials and labor costs. This is where the Chinese excel.

Tyler

[Shooter]

Castle go boom: Replacement sent free of charge!

Chinese go boom:

[driftah]

my turnigy 180 has taken a pounding and I would buy another anyday.I hear of just as many turnigy failures as castle failures around here.So much has to do with choosing the proper esc for the job...as a lot of people will say dont use over 4s on a castle etc and their turnigy smoked when i ran 6s with the bec on..etc etc.I also watched a few schulze esc's go up in flames on youtube whether its user error or not,who knows.I would rather buy 3 t180's then one castle as long as you set it up right and dont push it.My friends hate me because I run cheap esc's and get way more than I pay for..but my day will come....someday.

[Boomer]

Ok, we are making some progress. Those of you that have manufacturing experience know that companies offering warranty programs factor into their pricing the cost of repair or replacement. It is usually "factored" by using known or anticipated failure rates. So, we can assume that Castle includes this in their pricing, and for a direct comparison HK does not.

One member has observed that the MOSFETS are not the same, that solders are done differently, have different CAPS, and suggests that less pure copper maybe used on their circuit boards.... This is good information, if we know that the differences translate to higher quality, or are they just different methods of manufacturing?

It would be hard find hard data on the failure rates of either product for a number of reason's, primarily because of the wide range of how a person uses, or abuses the product, and the variables in the conditions, and finally the wide range of combinations of batteries, motors, props the ESC has to deal with.

In summary it appears that the pricing difference can be in part attributed to Castle having good warranty and replacement program. Further, that Castle does R&D which could suggest they have designed a higher quality product, but unless they make theirs in the US, this has to be tempered with the fact of it being made in China. I am guessing the Castle is made in China.

Thank you all for your replies!!!

I am reminded of my friends that drink and buy the higher priced vodkas; Grey Goose, Chopin or Stoli or Absolute and tell me how much better it is, and that they don't like the cheaper brands. I like their vodka too, because it is free!

When I buy vodka, I buy Smirnoff vodka. For fun I put my Vodka it in a High dollar vodka bottle, and served it to them out of the freezer and straight up. Not one of them noticed a difference. Ok, so it is not exactly the same comparison, but it is similar.

I accept that Vodkas are made in many different ways, and with different ingredients, and I accept the same of ESCs, but I think for my first experience with a higher amp ESC, I am going to try the Turnigy. I will document the application and the results moving forward until I fail one or two.

Thank you all! Very interesting stuff!!

Boomer